react-flow-architecture

$npx mdskill add existential-birds/beagle/react-flow-architecture

Architect node-based UIs with React Flow using proven patterns.

  • Evaluates whether React Flow fits a given use case.
  • Depends on React Flow library and its callback APIs.
  • Uses a decision workflow with gates for scale and state placement.
  • Delivers architectural guidance and node count guidelines.

SKILL.md

.github/skills/react-flow-architectureView on GitHub ↗
---
name: react-flow-architecture
description: Architectural guidance for building node-based UIs with React Flow. Use when designing flow-based applications, making decisions about state management, integration patterns, or evaluating whether React Flow fits a use case.
---

# React Flow Architecture

## When to Use React Flow

### Good Fit

- Visual programming interfaces
- Workflow builders and automation tools
- Diagram editors (flowcharts, org charts)
- Data pipeline visualization
- Mind mapping tools
- Node-based audio/video editors
- Decision tree builders
- State machine designers

### Consider Alternatives

- Simple static diagrams (use SVG or canvas directly)
- Heavy real-time collaboration (may need custom sync layer)
- 3D visualizations (use Three.js, react-three-fiber)
- Graph analysis with 10k+ nodes (use WebGL-based solutions like Sigma.js)

### Decision workflow (gates)

Run this sequence before locking the stack or sprinting implementation. Skip only for throwaway prototypes.

1. **Name the interactions** — List the top user actions (e.g. drag, connect, delete, group). **Pass:** Each action maps to a concrete React Flow callback you will implement (`onNodesChange`, `onConnect`, …).

2. **Classify scale** — Estimate peak nodes (visible canvas or document total). **Pass:** Your range matches a row in [Node Count Guidelines](#node-count-guidelines) and you accept the listed strategy (e.g. `onlyRenderVisibleElements` when that row implies it).

3. **Place state** — Choose local hooks, an external store, or Redux/other. **Pass:** One sentence states where persistence, undo, or cross-surface sync will live, or explicitly “not needed yet.”

4. **Re-check alternatives** — If the use case matches [Consider Alternatives](#consider-alternatives), **Pass:** One sentence explains why React Flow still fits or which listed alternative you chose instead.

## Architecture Patterns

### Package Structure (xyflow)

```
@xyflow/system (vanilla TypeScript)
├── Core algorithms (edge paths, bounds, viewport)
├── xypanzoom (d3-based pan/zoom)
├── xydrag, xyhandle, xyminimap, xyresizer
└── Shared types

@xyflow/react (depends on @xyflow/system)
├── React components and hooks
├── Zustand store for state management
└── Framework-specific integrations

@xyflow/svelte (depends on @xyflow/system)
└── Svelte components and stores
```

**Implication**: Core logic is framework-agnostic. When contributing or debugging, check if issue is in @xyflow/system or framework-specific package.

### State Management Approaches

#### 1. Local State (Simple Apps)

```tsx
// useNodesState/useEdgesState for prototyping
const [nodes, setNodes, onNodesChange] = useNodesState(initialNodes);
const [edges, setEdges, onEdgesChange] = useEdgesState(initialEdges);
```

**Pros**: Simple, minimal boilerplate
**Cons**: State isolated to component tree

#### 2. External Store (Production)

```tsx
// Zustand store example
import { create } from 'zustand';

interface FlowStore {
  nodes: Node[];
  edges: Edge[];
  setNodes: (nodes: Node[]) => void;
  onNodesChange: OnNodesChange;
}

const useFlowStore = create<FlowStore>((set, get) => ({
  nodes: initialNodes,
  edges: initialEdges,
  setNodes: (nodes) => set({ nodes }),
  onNodesChange: (changes) => {
    set({ nodes: applyNodeChanges(changes, get().nodes) });
  },
}));

// In component
function Flow() {
  const { nodes, edges, onNodesChange } = useFlowStore();
  return <ReactFlow nodes={nodes} onNodesChange={onNodesChange} />;
}
```

**Pros**: State accessible anywhere, easier persistence/sync
**Cons**: More setup, need careful selector optimization

#### 3. Redux/Other State Libraries

```tsx
// Connect via selectors
const nodes = useSelector(selectNodes);
const dispatch = useDispatch();

const onNodesChange = useCallback((changes: NodeChange[]) => {
  dispatch(nodesChanged(changes));
}, [dispatch]);
```

### Data Flow Architecture

```
User Input → Change Event → Reducer/Handler → State Update → Re-render
     ↓
[Drag node] → onNodesChange → applyNodeChanges → setNodes → ReactFlow
     ↓
[Connect]   → onConnect → addEdge → setEdges → ReactFlow
     ↓
[Delete]    → onNodesDelete → deleteElements → setNodes/setEdges → ReactFlow
```

### Sub-Flow Pattern (Nested Nodes)

```tsx
// Parent node containing child nodes
const nodes = [
  {
    id: 'group-1',
    type: 'group',
    position: { x: 0, y: 0 },
    style: { width: 300, height: 200 },
  },
  {
    id: 'child-1',
    parentId: 'group-1',  // Key: parent reference
    extent: 'parent',      // Key: constrain to parent
    position: { x: 10, y: 30 },  // Relative to parent
    data: { label: 'Child' },
  },
];
```

**Considerations**:
- Use `extent: 'parent'` to constrain dragging
- Use `expandParent: true` to auto-expand parent
- Parent z-index affects child rendering order

### Viewport Persistence

```tsx
// Save viewport state
const { toObject, setViewport } = useReactFlow();

const handleSave = () => {
  const flow = toObject();
  // flow.nodes, flow.edges, flow.viewport
  localStorage.setItem('flow', JSON.stringify(flow));
};

const handleRestore = () => {
  const flow = JSON.parse(localStorage.getItem('flow'));
  setNodes(flow.nodes);
  setEdges(flow.edges);
  setViewport(flow.viewport);
};
```

## Integration Patterns

### With Backend/API

```tsx
// Load from API
useEffect(() => {
  fetch('/api/flow')
    .then(r => r.json())
    .then(({ nodes, edges }) => {
      setNodes(nodes);
      setEdges(edges);
    });
}, []);

// Debounced auto-save
const debouncedSave = useMemo(
  () => debounce((nodes, edges) => {
    fetch('/api/flow', {
      method: 'POST',
      body: JSON.stringify({ nodes, edges }),
    });
  }, 1000),
  []
);

useEffect(() => {
  debouncedSave(nodes, edges);
}, [nodes, edges]);
```

### With Layout Algorithms

```tsx
import dagre from 'dagre';

function getLayoutedElements(nodes: Node[], edges: Edge[]) {
  const g = new dagre.graphlib.Graph();
  g.setGraph({ rankdir: 'TB' });
  g.setDefaultEdgeLabel(() => ({}));

  nodes.forEach((node) => {
    g.setNode(node.id, { width: 150, height: 50 });
  });

  edges.forEach((edge) => {
    g.setEdge(edge.source, edge.target);
  });

  dagre.layout(g);

  return {
    nodes: nodes.map((node) => {
      const pos = g.node(node.id);
      return { ...node, position: { x: pos.x, y: pos.y } };
    }),
    edges,
  };
}
```

## Performance Scaling

### Node Count Guidelines

| Nodes | Strategy |
|-------|----------|
| < 100 | Default settings |
| 100-500 | Enable `onlyRenderVisibleElements` |
| 500-1000 | Simplify custom nodes, reduce DOM elements |
| > 1000 | Consider virtualization, WebGL alternatives |

### Optimization Techniques

```tsx
<ReactFlow
  // Only render nodes/edges in viewport
  onlyRenderVisibleElements={true}

  // Reduce node border radius (improves intersect calculations)
  nodeExtent={[[-1000, -1000], [1000, 1000]]}

  // Disable features not needed
  elementsSelectable={false}
  panOnDrag={false}
  zoomOnScroll={false}
/>
```

## Trade-offs

### Controlled vs Uncontrolled

| Controlled | Uncontrolled |
|------------|--------------|
| More boilerplate | Less code |
| Full state control | Internal state |
| Easy persistence | Need `toObject()` |
| Better for complex apps | Good for prototypes |

### Connection Modes

| Strict (default) | Loose |
|------------------|-------|
| Source → Target only | Any handle → any handle |
| Predictable behavior | More flexible |
| Use for data flows | Use for diagrams |

```tsx
<ReactFlow connectionMode={ConnectionMode.Loose} />
```

### Edge Rendering

| Default edges | Custom edges |
|---------------|--------------|
| Fast rendering | More control |
| Limited styling | Any SVG/HTML |
| Simple use cases | Complex labels |

More from existential-birds/beagle

SkillDescription
adr-decision-extractionUse when you need to mine a conversation, session transcript, or design discussion for architectural decisions before writing ADRs. Identifies problem-solution pairs, trade-off debates, technology choices, and explicit \"[ADR]\" tags. Triggers on \"what decisions did we make\", \"extract decisions from this chat\", \"find the choices in our discussion\", or \"summarize architectural decisions\". Also useful after long planning sessions to capture decisions that were made implicitly. Does NOT write ADR documents \u2014 use adr-writing or write-adr for that.
adr-writingUse when writing or formatting an ADR document using the MADR template, applying Definition of Done (E.C.A.D.R.) criteria, or verifying ADR completeness. Triggers on \"write the ADR\", \"format as MADR\", \"check ADR quality\", \"mark gaps in ADR\". Also triggers when a decision has been extracted and needs to become a document. Does NOT extract decisions from conversations (use adr-decision-extraction) or orchestrate the full extract-confirm-write workflow (use write-adr).
agent-architecture-analysisUse when auditing an agent codebase against the 12-Factor Agents methodology, reviewing LLM-powered system architecture, or assessing agentic app compliance. Triggers on \"analyze agent architecture\", \"12-factor audit\", \"how compliant is this agent\", or \"evaluate this LLM app\". Also applies when comparing frameworks or planning agent improvements. Not for quick checklists \u2014 this performs deep per-factor codebase analysis with file-level evidence.
app-intents-code-reviewReviews App Intents code for intent structure, entities, shortcuts, and parameters. Use when reviewing code with import AppIntents, @AppIntent, AppEntity, AppShortcutsProvider, or @Parameter.
artifact-analysisUse when the user wants a cited, structured read of local documents and project knowledge. Triggers on: \"analyze these docs\", \"scan my project for context\", \"read the docs folder\", \"summarize what's in .beagle/concepts/\", \"extract context from docs/\", \"what's in this folder\", \"go read everything in X and tell me what's there\". Also invoked programmatically by other beagle skills (prfaq-beagle Ignition, brainstorm-beagle reference points, strategy-interview context grounding) via the companion contract. Does NOT trigger on codebase lookups (\"find this function\", \"search the repo\"), web research (use web-research), LLM-as-judge evaluation (use llm-judge), or document editing (use humanize-beagle). Produces a written scan plan, parallel-subagent findings, and a cited synthesis report on disk — never inline prose, never unsourced claims.
axum-code-reviewReviews axum web framework code for routing patterns, extractor usage, middleware, state management, and error handling. Use when reviewing Rust code that uses axum, tower, or hyper for HTTP services. Covers axum 0.7+ patterns including State, Path, Query, Json extractors.
brainstorm-beagleUse when the user has a fuzzy idea and wants to shape it into a concrete project spec before planning or building. Triggers on: \"brainstorm this\", \"I have an idea for...\", \"help me think through this project\", \"what should I build\", \"spec this out\". Also catches vague feature descriptions needing structured questioning to clarify scope. Does NOT write code, plan implementation, review strategy docs, or run strategy interviews \u2014 produces a WHAT/WHY spec through dialogue, not a HOW plan.
bubbletea-code-reviewReviews BubbleTea TUI code for proper Elm architecture, model/update/view patterns, and Lipgloss styling. Use when reviewing terminal UI code using charmbracelet/bubbletea.
cloudkit-code-reviewReviews CloudKit code for container setup, record handling, subscriptions, and sharing patterns. Use when reviewing code with import CloudKit, CKContainer, CKRecord, CKShare, or CKSubscription.
combine-code-reviewReviews Combine framework code for memory leaks, operator misuse, and error handling. Use when reviewing code with import Combine, AnyPublisher, @Published, PassthroughSubject, or CurrentValueSubject.