go-generics

$npx mdskill add cxuu/golang-skills/go-generics

Guide when to use Go generics and how to write generic code.

  • Helps decide between generics, interfaces, and concrete types for reusable logic.
  • Depends on Go 1.18+ compiler and standard library support for type parameters.
  • Uses a decision flow based on type count and interface suitability.
  • Provides code examples and references to constraints and type sets.

SKILL.md

.github/skills/go-genericsView on GitHub ↗
---
name: go-generics
description: Use when deciding whether to use Go generics, writing generic functions or types, choosing constraints, or picking between type aliases and type definitions. Also use when a user is writing a utility function that could work with multiple types, even if they don't mention generics explicitly. Does not cover interface design without generics (see go-interfaces).
---

# Go Generics and Type Parameters

> Compatibility: Generics require Go 1.18+.

## Resource Routing

- `references/CONSTRAINTS.md` - Read when composing constraints, using type sets, or choosing between generics and interfaces.

## When to Use Generics

Start with concrete types. Generalize only when a second type appears.

### Prefer Generics When

- Multiple types share identical logic (sorting, filtering, map/reduce)
- You would otherwise rely on `any` and excessive type switching
- You are building a reusable data structure (concurrent-safe set, ordered map)

### Avoid Generics When

- Only one type is being instantiated in practice
- Interfaces already model the shared behavior cleanly
- The generic code is harder to read than the type-specific alternative

> "Write code, don't design types." — Robert Griesemer and Ian Lance Taylor

### Decision Flow

```
Do multiple types share identical logic?
├─ No  → Use concrete types
├─ Yes → Do they share a useful interface?
│        ├─ Yes → Use an interface
│        └─ No  → Use generics
```

**Bad:**

```go
// Premature generics: only ever called with int
func Sum[T constraints.Integer | constraints.Float](vals []T) T {
    var total T
    for _, v := range vals {
        total += v
    }
    return total
}
```

**Good:**

```go
func SumInts(vals []int) int {
    var total int
    for _, v := range vals {
        total += v
    }
    return total
}
```

---

## Type Parameter Naming

| Name | Typical Use |
|------|-------------|
| `T` | General type parameter |
| `K` | Map key type |
| `V` | Map value type |
| `E` | Element/item type |

For complex constraints, a short descriptive name is acceptable:

```go
func Marshal[Opts encoding.MarshalOptions](v any, opts Opts) ([]byte, error)
```

---

## Type Aliases vs Type Definitions

Type aliases (`type Old = new.Name`) are rare — use only for package migration
or gradual API refactoring.

---

## Constraint Composition

Combine constraints with `~` (underlying type) and `|` (union):

```go
type Numeric interface {
    ~int | ~int8 | ~int16 | ~int32 | ~int64 |
    ~float32 | ~float64
}

func Sum[T Numeric](vals []T) T {
    var total T
    for _, v := range vals {
        total += v
    }
    return total
}
```

Use the `constraints` package or `cmp` package (Go 1.21+) for standard constraints
like `cmp.Ordered` instead of writing your own.

---

## Common Pitfalls

### Don't Wrap Standard Library Types

```go
// Bad: generic wrapper adds complexity without value
type Set[T comparable] struct {
    m map[T]struct{}
}

// Better: use map[T]struct{} directly when the usage is simple
seen := map[string]struct{}{}
```

Generics justify their complexity when they eliminate duplication across
**multiple call sites**. A single-use generic is just indirection.

### Don't Use Generics for Interface Satisfaction

```go
// Bad: T is only used to satisfy an interface — just use the interface
func Process[T io.Reader](r T) error { ... }

// Good: accept the interface directly
func Process(r io.Reader) error { ... }
```

### Avoid Over-Constraining

```go
// Bad: constraint is more restrictive than needed
func Contains[T interface{ ~int | ~string }](slice []T, target T) bool { ... }

// Good: comparable is sufficient
func Contains[T comparable](slice []T, target T) bool { ... }
```

---

## Quick Reference

| Topic | Guidance |
|-------|----------|
| When to use generics | Only when multiple types share identical logic and interfaces don't suffice |
| Starting point | Write concrete code first; generalize later |
| Naming | Single uppercase letter (`T`, `K`, `V`, `E`) |
| Type aliases | Same type, alternate name; use only for migration |
| Constraint composition | Use `~` for underlying types, `|` for unions; prefer `cmp.Ordered` over custom |
| Common pitfall | Don't genericize single-use code or when interfaces suffice |

---

## Related Skills

- **Interfaces vs generics**: See [go-interfaces](../go-interfaces/SKILL.md) when deciding whether an interface already models the shared behavior without generics
- **Type declarations**: See [go-declarations](../go-declarations/SKILL.md) when defining new types, type aliases, or choosing between type definitions and aliases
- **Documenting generic APIs**: See [go-documentation](../go-documentation/SKILL.md) when writing doc comments and runnable examples for generic functions
- **Naming type parameters**: See [go-naming](../go-naming/SKILL.md) when choosing names for type parameters or constraint interfaces

More from cxuu/golang-skills

SkillDescription
go-code-reviewUse when reviewing Go code or checking code against community style standards. Also use proactively before submitting a Go PR or when reviewing any Go code changes, even if the user doesn't explicitly request a style review. Does not cover language-specific syntax — delegates to specialized skills.
go-concurrencyUse when writing concurrent Go code — goroutines, channels, mutexes, or thread-safety guarantees. Also use when parallelizing work, fixing data races, or protecting shared state, even if the user doesn't explicitly mention concurrency primitives. Does not cover context.Context patterns (see go-context).
go-contextUse when working with context.Context in Go — placement in signatures, propagating cancellation and deadlines, and storing values in context vs parameters. Also use when cancelling long-running operations, setting timeouts, or passing request-scoped data, even if they don't mention context.Context directly. Does not cover goroutine lifecycle or sync primitives (see go-concurrency).
go-control-flowUse when writing conditionals, loops, or switch statements in Go — including if with initialization, early returns, for loop forms, range, switch, type switches, and blank identifier patterns. Also use when writing a simple if/else or for loop, even if the user doesn't mention guard clauses or variable scoping. Does not cover error flow patterns (see go-error-handling).
go-data-structuresUse when working with Go slices, maps, or arrays — choosing between new and make, using append, declaring empty slices (nil vs literal for JSON), implementing sets with maps, and copying data at boundaries. Also use when building or manipulating collections, even if the user doesn't ask about allocation idioms. Does not cover concurrent data structure safety (see go-concurrency).
go-declarationsUse when declaring or initializing Go variables, constants, structs, or maps — including var vs :=, reducing scope with if-init, formatting composite literals, designing iota enums, and using any instead of interface{}. Also use when writing a new struct or const block, even if the user doesn't ask about declaration style. Does not cover naming conventions (see go-naming).
go-defensiveUse when hardening Go code at API boundaries — copying slices/maps, verifying interface compliance, using defer for cleanup, time.Time/time.Duration, or avoiding mutable globals. Also use when reviewing for robustness concerns like missing cleanup or unsafe crypto usage, even if the user doesn't mention "defensive programming." Does not cover error handling strategy (see go-error-handling).
go-documentationUse when writing or reviewing documentation for Go packages, types, functions, or methods. Also use proactively when creating new exported types, functions, or packages, even if the user doesn't explicitly ask about documentation. Does not cover code comments for non-exported symbols (see go-style-core).
go-error-handlingUse when writing Go code that returns, wraps, or handles errors — choosing between sentinel errors, custom types, and fmt.Errorf (%w vs %v), structuring error flow, or deciding whether to log or return. Also use when propagating errors across package boundaries or using errors.Is/As, even if the user doesn't ask about error strategy. Does not cover panic/recover patterns (see go-defensive).
go-functional-optionsUse when designing a Go constructor or factory function with optional configuration — especially with 3+ optional parameters or extensible APIs. Also use when building a New* function that takes many settings, even if they don't mention "functional options" by name. Does not cover general function design (see go-functions).